Skip to main content
Research has 3 jobs: finding the sources, reasoning from them, and checking the work. Who does each job has changed twice. Each change moved work from a person to a machine, and each asked something else of the data.

Before search engines, a person did all 3 jobs

A researcher found a book through a library’s catalog, read it, and took notes with the page number. A reviewer checked the work by opening the book at that page. The citation was the check: an author, a title, and a page were enough for anyone to find the sentence again.

With search engines, a person still read the page

A search engine took over part of the first job. It returned 10 links, ranked for a person who would open the first one. The page behind a link was made for a person to look at: a header, a menu, advertising, and somewhere among them the article. The person skipped what surrounds the text without thinking about it. The person saw that a clause was struck through, that one heading of a table spans 3 columns, and that a ministry’s page is not a blog. None of this was written down anywhere, because a person’s eyes did it.

With agents, the reader is a program

An agent does the second job, the reasoning, and it does the first one in a loop: it searches, reads, judges what it found, and searches again, many times for one question, with nobody watching most of the steps. This reader differs from a person in 3 ways.
  • An agent cannot see. To a model, a menu is text like the article, text hidden in a page is text too, and a table without its structure is a run of numbers.
  • An agent cannot read everything. Its context is limited, so a 300-page agreement has to reach it in parts, and it has to choose the parts before it has read them.
  • An agent is not the last reader. Its report goes to a person, a client, an auditor, or a court, and that reader has to be able to check a claim without doing the research again.
A page made to be looked at serves none of the 3.

A data layer returns what a person did without writing it down

What a person did while reading, by looking or by habit, comes to an agent as data.

The check has to cost less than the work

A report that cannot be checked has to be believed, and a careful reader does not believe it. So the third job, the check, decides whether the work of an agent can be used at all. A check is worth having only if it costs much less than the work it checks. For that reason every record is stored, every passage has a place that stays the same, and every value says what it rests on: a quote found word for word, a passage that a model judged, a field that the source does not state, a page that was not read. A second agent, or a person with one call, can open the passage behind a sentence and see whether the words are there. For the calls that do this, see From a question to a checked report.